A recent article in The Economist claims climate change is harming the production of coffee and tea in East Africa; Kenya in particular. This is false. [bold, links added]
As the Earth has modestly warmed, coffee and tea production in East Africa has repeatedly set new records. Kenya is a mixed bag. Although coffee production has declined, tea production has increased dramatically.
The article describes diminishing coffee and tea production amid global warming, along with a decrease in the flavor of coffee beans, but real-world crop statistics prove these assertions are mostly false.
The article, ‘Why global warming threatens east African coffee,’ describes a calamitous future for coffee and tea production in East Africa in general, and Kenya in particular.
The Economist reports:
Warming weather in east Africa, the birthplace of coffee, is already beginning to harm one of the region’s most important export crops, which is worth some $2bn a year. Overheating coffee shrubs also foreshadow the harm that may befall other vital crops such as tea, Kenya’s biggest export.
And if coffee becomes more expensive or less tasty, it is not just farmers who will suffer, but the big chunk of humanity who together glug down some 3bn cups of the stuff a day, at a cost of about $200bn a year.
The United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) tracks crop production and yield data for individual countries, regions, and globally.
According to FAO data, coffee and tea production in Eastern Africa has increased substantially since between 2000 and 2020, a period which climate alarmists have repeatedly claimed is the warmest on record, as seen in the chart below.
According to FAO data:
- Coffee production in East Africa has increased by approximately 57 percent;
- Tea production in East Africa has grown by about more than 97 percent;
- Tea production in Kenya has expanded by more than 142 percent.
Over the period, Kenya’s coffee production has declined slightly but remained overall relatively flat.
As neighboring countries like Ethiopia and Uganda continue to see rising coffee production amid modest warming, there is limited evidence climate change is responsible for Kenya’s nearly static coffee production.
Evidence suggests any decline in Kenyan coffee production is from a variety of factors unrelated to climate change or weather.
For example, suburban growth has expanded into traditional coffee plantation regions of Kenya.
In addition, competition from neighboring nations, mismanagement, and government corruption have also negatively affected coffee production in Kenya.
What is true of East Africa, is true for most countries, regions, and the Earth as a whole. Coffee production has regularly set records across the past 20 years, as explored in Climate Realism here and here, for example.
Concerning the claim that coffee is becoming less tasty, to be clear, the taste of coffee is subjective.
Coffee and type of bean, regional product, or a brand that may taste sublime to some people might taste awful to others, and vice-versa. There is no objective evidence coffee is becoming less “tasty.”
As discussed in a Climate Realism article, here, the oft-repeated line that the best tasting coffee beans—like Arabica—are suffering from decreased production due to global warming is untrue.
The opposite is true, according to global data. Since 2005, Arabica coffee has seen a 25 percent increase in yield.
Also, as discussed in Climate Realism here, the ongoing growth in coffee consumption argues strongly against such a subjective claim.
Indeed, there are more different varieties and hybrid varieties of coffee produced and sold today than has ever existed in history.
There is virtually a flavor profile to fit every taste, and major coffee companies are growing and experimenting to further enhance taste.
Rather than reporting these facts, The Economist chose, as so many corporate media outlets do these days, to take anecdotal evidence from a single person or group’s experience and extrapolate it into a climate-alarm disaster story.
Read more at Climate Realism
Trackback from your site.